Ripple's Humans First IT Blog

Outsourced IT Security vs. In-House: What’s Best for You?

Written by Mike Landman | Jul 19, 2019

Cybercriminals purposely exploit small businesses because they tend not to take their security and IT as seriously. In other words, they’re easier targets:

What stops SMBs from gearing up with IT and security solutions?

There are several common barriers:

  • Lack of Proper Expertise: You need people who understand security and your specific vulnerabilities.
  • Lack of Time: Even if you’re willing to learn, it’s a time sink that requires constant vigilance.
  • Lack of Money: Security solutions and the people to run them can cost a pretty penny.

So, what are your options? Well, you can outsource your IT and cybersecurity or bring it in-house.

In this blog, we’ll break down the advantages and disadvantages of in-house IT vs. outsourcing and discuss whether in-house IT support is the right choice for you.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Outsourcing IT Security?

You could go back and forth for days about the advantages and disadvantages of outsourcing IT. However, here are a few we think are the most important.

The Pros

  1. Access to Broader Expertise: Security threats and tech problems happen faster than most internal teams can keep up with. With an outsourced partner, you can tap into a team of specialists who live and breathe IT.

  2. 24/7 Monitoring and Faster Response Times: Incidents and downtime don’t care about business hours. The right IT partner brings around-the-clock detection, threat hunting, and response so you can put your phone down without worrying about whether everything is going to fall apart.

  3. Predictable Costs: Hiring, training, and retaining senior-level IT staff add up quickly. With outsourced security, you get great coverage without the overhead, turnover risk, or budget surprises.

  4. Scales With Your Needs: Whether you're onboarding 10 new employees next month or rolling out new cloud infrastructure, outsource IT teams can scale up (or down) faster than internal teams.

 

The Cons

  1. They’re Not In Your Building: Sometimes, it’s helpful to walk down the hall and ask a question or troubleshoot a problem with tech. Outsourced teams aren’t physically there. While tools like Slack and Teams bridge the gap, it’s something to consider.

  2. Takes Some Upfront Coordination: Good outsourced IT takes setup, onboarding, and a learning curve. But the best providers make that process smooth and collaborative.

  3. Trust Isn’t Automatic: When you outsource, you’re putting sensitive systems and data in someone else’s hands. That requires real trust. The right partner earns that trust with transparency, clear communication, and provable processes.

 

Here’s the real difference between in-house IT vs. outsourcing:

Outsourced IT management has the expert staff and tools to protect you, but they’re also equipped to keep you running strategically. When you grow, your IT grows too, so your operations are always supported.

In addition to getting your day-to-day support handled, you can get your network and computers secured along with other important services, like backup, monitoring, consulting, and more.

Pros and Cons of In-House IT Support

For smaller companies, hiring a dedicated in-house IT support person might feel like the safest move. You get someone on-site, full-time who knows your system and your people. Their response times are usually fast, and their familiarity is excellent.

But here’s the reality:

95% of businesses with fewer than 100 employees don’t have a single information security professional on staff. And fewer than 30% of SMBs manage their security fully in-house.

Why? Because one person can only cover so much ground.

Most in-house IT support hires are IT generalists. They’re asked to juggle onboarding, password resets, Wi-Fi issues, device management, vendor tools, cybersecurity, etc.. It’s not that they’re bad at their jobs.
 
It’s that no one person can be an expert in everything.

If you go this route, just know that you’re getting a solid day-to-day helper. But probably not deep security strategy, 24/7 monitoring, or scalable protection.

Cost Comparison: In-House IT vs. Outsourcing

In-House IT Support Costs

The average salary for a mid-to-senior IT analyst hire in 2025 is $88,753. That’s before benefits, training, software licenses, and some trial-and-error hiring.

And, if you need more than one person, that number can be multiplied quickly. On top of that, you’ll need to account for vacation time, off-hours incidents, or resignation.

What we’re trying to say is that the costs can compound fast. If you’re hoping one person can handle endpoint protection, employee training, cloud security, risk assessments, and compliance audits, that’s a big ask. Putting that much responsibility on their shoulders is a disservice to your business as well as the person trying to keep your IT in check.

Outsourced IT Management Costs

Good outsourced IT partners price by user. That means your monthly cost is based on:

  • How many users you have
  • How many offices or locations you support
  • What percentage of your team is remote
  • What compliance standards you need to meet (HIPAA, SOC 2, etc.)

The per-user pricing model is more fair and it scales with your team. As your company grows or contracts, your IT support adjusts to it without awkward hiring gaps, sunk costs, or drama.

Is Outsourced IT Management Secure and Compliant?

Short answer: It can be. But not all providers are created equal.

Security and compliance require ongoing processes that require constant oversight.

What Companies Worry About (And Should):

Compliance Requirements
Whether it’s HIPAA, SOC 2, PCI-DSS, or something industry-specific, compliance is critical. This is essential to protecting your business.

Data Control
You should know where your data is being stored, who has access, and who can revoke it.

Visibility
If your outsourced IT management partners' processes are muddled, that’s a red flag. You need clear lines of communication, documentation, and accountability.

What to Look for in a Provider:

Documented Processes and Reporting
A good provider doesn’t just say they’re secure, they show you the work behind it. Ask for reporting dashboards, audit logs, and security workflows.

Proven Compliance and Certifications
SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001, and HIPAA-readiness are non-negotiables. They’re proof that your partner takes security as seriously as you do.

Clear SLAs and Escalation Paths
If something goes wrong, who’s responsible for the fix? Make sure your agreement includes clear expectations around response times, communication, and incident handling.

Which Is Better: Outsourced IT Security or In-House Security?

The honest answer? It depends. On your size, your industry, your risk tolerance, and how much your internal team can realistically take on. 

There’s no one-size-fits-all; only what fits best for you.

When in-house IT support might work best:

  • You’ve already built a mature IT team with the right mix of security talent
  • You have the budget to hire, train, and retain multiple specialists
  • Your business needs highly customized tools or proprietary systems that require hands-on oversight
When outsourced IT management wins:
  • You need expert-level support but can’t justify adding another full-time salary
  • Your internal IT lead is drowning in tickets and doesn’t have time to focus on strategy
  • You want a partner who brings best practices, guidance, and some extra firepower

When co-managed IT is the right fit:
Going full outsourced IT or in-house IT may not be the solution for everybody. Luckily, co-managed IT blends both.

You keep your internal team focused on what they do best, while a partner takes care of:
  • Security monitoring
  • Patching and updates
  • Backup and disaster recovery
  • Strategic planning
  • User support overflow

If you need help with your IT or bridging the gap in your IT operations, co-managed IT might be the solution for you. It can help you save on costs and easily scale resources based on your changing business needs.

What to Look for in Outsourced IT Management

Sadly, not all MSPs are built the same. It’s very much in your best interest to reach out to them and make sure that it’s a good fit. Whether it’s security or daily support, the premise is the same: this is your new IT department.

Don’t hire one you don’t like. And especially don’t hire one that doesn’t fit your needs.

Something like IT should never be a one-size-fits-all approach. There are still different needs you may have, so you’ll want to communicate them with the MSP to discover your next steps to securing your business.

And hey, while you’re here…that’s actually what Ripple does. We can help you get started on your path to peace of mind with strategic, helpful IT that puts your people, not your computers, first.

If you’re ready to get started, chat with Melissa, our Director of Strategy and Revenue. She’ll let you in on how Ripple’s outsourced IT management has helped hundreds of other organizations like yours do the best work of their careers by not worrying about IT.